NEWS ARTICLE
August 3, 2006

Outside groups fuel 7th District race

WASHINGTON —Two Washington-based groups, the conservative Club for Growth and the moderate Republican Main Street Partnership, are spending hundreds of thousands of dollars to back opposing candidates in Michigan's 7th Congressional District primary race.

Freshman GOP Rep. Joe Schwarz of Battle Creek and Tim Walberg, a former minister and state representative from Tipton, will face off the in the Republican primary election on Tuesday.

The Club for Growth and a tax-exempt affiliate have spent $392,989 to buy broadcast advertising and send mailings that support Walberg, according to Michigan Campaign Finance Network, a Lansing group that researches money in state politics.

In addition, the Club for Growth has solicited $476,709 in donations from among its 36,000 members around the country and forwarded them to Walberg, Michigan Campaign Finance Network numbers show.

Club President Pat Toomey says Walberg supports the club's goal of a limited federal government that enacts pro-growth economic policies, and Schwarz does not.

"(Schwarz) is a supporter of the whole culture of excessive (government) spending," Toomey said in an interview. He is a former three-term GOP congressman from Pennsylvania.

The Republican Main Street Partnership, which represents 48 members of Congress and four governors, has spent $470,000 to buy broadcast advertising and send mailings that support Schwarz, executive director Sarah Chamberlain Resnick said in an interview.

The group, whose members describe themselves as conservative on economic issues and moderate on social issues, jumped into the Schwarz-Walberg race because they believe fellow GOP lawmakers shouldn't be challenged in primaries, Resnick said.

"We follow Ronald Reagan's 11th commandment, which is, 'Thou shall not speak ill of your own.' " Resnick said.

Schwarz won Michigan's 7th District seat in 2004 after defeating Walberg and four other conservative Republicans in a primary election two years ago. At that time, Republican Main Street Partnership backed Schwarz and Club for Growth supported Brad Smith of Addison, the son of then-Rep. Nick Smith, who retired. Brad Smith came in second and Walberg finished third.

Resnick said the Club for Growth wanted revenge this year, after its candidate lost two years ago.

Toomey denied that.

"People ought to just acknowledge that we've got honest differences over policy," he said.

This year's battle has produced some unusual patterns in the money flowing into and out of the campaign war chests, according to the Center for Responsive Politics, a Washington group that tracks money in politics.

  • Only 13 percent of Schwarz's money comes from outside of Michigan, but 76 percent of Walberg's money is from outside the state. Typically, an incumbent draws more money from outside his state because he is better known than his challenger, center spokesman Massie Ritsch said.
     
  • Schwarz has spent almost $1 million on his campaign, leaving him with just under $400,000 in campaign funds — about the same as Walberg's remaining funds. It's rare that a challenger can match an incumbent's available cash, Ritsch said.
  •